Pizzeria New York - Feedback

Just ordered wings, white pizza and pepperoni pizza. Awesome!

I just wish I would’ve known sooner! My wife and I had the pepperoni rolls and the pin wheels! They were so good I didn’t even get a chance to take picture! Don...

Has been a while since I sat inside and ate. Although I asked about table service, there really isn't because you have to order at the counter yourself. The atm...

Our first time eating here. The pizza was great and looked like a pizza artist put it together lol. It was gorgeous! My only complaint is that we ordered old wo...

One of the better New York style pizzas in pickerington

I grew up with Mom and Pop Italian restaurants. I'm not a big fan of Domino's pizza, pizza hat and all these pizza chains. I love folding my pizza. They also ha...

This was our first time here and we were very impressed. This shop was highly recommended. We chose this place because of the dune. Ordered a 16 pepperoni, brea...

We've been ordering their pizza every two weeks since November. It always comes hot and fresh. The waiting time is a little longer, but it is worth it.

Pizza is so delicious, crust is so thin, but also not soggy and the sauce to cheese ratio is perfection, so good

This place has the best pizza! I love their style of pizza, the pepperoni pinwheels and their cannolis. I'd give them 5 stars, but the cook on my pizza has been...

Best pizza in Pickerington. Not quite like NYC/NJ but for the east side of Columbus it?s great!

Ordered online, pizza came out of the oven right at the specified time and it was excellent. I'll absolutely be returning again in the future. Fantastic pizza,...

Do not sleep on this place! My family and I visited on a weeknight, and the place was completely empty. Considering how good the pizza is, we were shocked. Alth...

This place was recommended by a friend however I found it to be disappointing. I was born and raised in New York and I know authentic New York style when I tast...

Had an excellent NY style pizza as you would expect! Delicious! Great salad as well!