The Attic - Stoney Creek

Warning to anyone who loved the Attic Pizza in Stoney Creek. Ownership change in November and it is now the WORST PIZZA EVER!! The crust was horrible, like three week old cardboard. Everything else about it made the crust look good. It is NOT the Attic you have known.

Went in here tonight (Monday) and found it to be a nice place inside with wooden walls but it was too small. Only two regular size booths and they had to turn away a lot of people wanting to sit at the back as they were reserving a table for 18--yikes! Luckily we got a booth. The patio outside was a good size. The server greeted us quickly, she was friendly, although she kept sitting at the bar on the side with the other customers, which seemed odd to us. When she came around, we asked about the wings that were on special (only $2 off) at $9.99 per pound--about 9 wings. We ordered a pound of breaded mild wings and a pound of unbreaded hot extra crispy. We had to wait 25 minutes for them. They both tasted good, but they were very small, and they gave us hardly any celery and carrot sticks--not worth it, even at the special price. We also ordered a couple of special medium one-topping pizzas to go. They don't allow you to add more toppings for that deal. As you can see by the pictures they put a good amount of sausage on one of them, but hardly any pepperoni on the other. The crust was very dry, and was not thick, and not thin, somewhere in between. The sauce on the pizza was sweet but the whole pizza really didn't have a lot of taste to it.

Holy cats! I've never been so disappointed in my life! It took them 1 hour and 15 minutes to get my order ready. Cold food, tough chicken wings, the fries were a mixture of soggy, greasy and hard, and they forgot part of my order. SKIP refunded me completely! We will never order from the Attic again!

Pizza is excellent. Service is excellent. Overall presentation of establishment is fair. My wife and i were there with our 10 month old son yesterday (Sunday) at 5pm for a quick pizza. Upon arrival the nice server 'warned us ' that it is very loud because of an event going on. She recommended the patio but it was too windy for us so we decided to stay inside. The group at the bar was ridiculously loud and obnoxious BUT it is a bar afterall. We weren 't too upset about it. BUT the 2 servers were very embarrassed and concerned about the loudness and behaviour of the bar patrons. They kept apologizing to us and also telling the bar to be quiet. Long story short, one of the drunk guys paid for our meal. The servers did an excellent job dealing with the 'situation '. We enjoyed our meal.

Wow! Haven't been here for about 30 years. What a tragedy. This used to be one of the best pizzas on the Niagara peninsula but now it it absolutely horrible. Go to fortinos for a much better pizza. Not the best but light years ahead of the Attic. I cannot tell how disappointed I am. Utterly horrible.