Two Guys Pizza - Richmond

New to the area and was looking for something similar to the NY pizza I ate growing up. I initially stumbled upon this place and was pleasantly surprised. I recently visited again and noticed there was new management and figured it would be the same pizza. I was very wrong. The pizza is thick and undercooked, the sauce was sweet and best yet, the prices had doubled. That’s not an exaggeration. The regular slice was $2.89 and it is now $5.99, the pepperoni was $3.79 and now it is $6.99…. I know this because they had left the old sign with prices by the bathroom see pic. Also ordered a pepperoni roll, received a bacon roll, didn’t want to make a fuss so took a bite, salty and fatty with a side of cold tomato sauce… I don’t ever write reviews but I’m annoyed by the greed, service and product. Disappointed, back to the search.

Big slice, cheap price… but top was kinda raw and the sauce is kinda… yucky. I wiped it off with a napkin. Really sweet tomato paste with just an off-putting flavor.

We’ve been coming to Two Guys for years. Was great. Ordered two pizzas from them in June of ‘24…. Something has drastically changed. Pizza was terrible. We even threw the second pizza away (that we usually have as leftovers). That’s right, I hate wasting food, but could not bring myself to eat it. Family actually thought maybe cheese was very expired. Will have to find a different place for NY style pizza.

They had a Buffalo chicken pizza that was my favorite pizza on the planet. Now they’re owned by Mantu, and they changed how it’s made, ruining it

We’ve always loved 2 Guys Pizza but now that it’s under new management, the recipe has changed and the ambiance is unacceptable. Employee children are set up throughout the dining room. The pizza genuinely isn’t as good. The seasoning is off, pizza tastes like bowling alley pizza that’s been sitting under a lamp for a few hours. Our local favorite is gone, short pump residents need a new authentic pizza spot! We won’t be back (after years of loyal service).