New York Bagel Cafe - Newburgh

So far the best bialy and egg bagel in the area! The place is always busy and you have to get there early to get a full selection. I don’t give 5 stars often but it is worth it. Good prices too! Anyone new to the area, make sure you get in line or you will be passed up. Regulars know the drill and can be in and out of there quickly.

Best bacon egg and cheese on a bagel you can get around here. The bacon is always perfectly crispy and the everything bagel seasoning is top notch. The staff is also very friendly!

Best bagels around, been coming here for years now. Service has been phenomenal, especially post-quarantine. My egg sandwich is always spot on it’s been especially speedy lately to pick up an order even when it’s very busy. I’ve noticed a few new staff members and have to say things have vastly improved (even though they were always good) since then. My only suggestion would be to add additional phone lines or an online ordering system as sometimes it is very difficult to get through to place an order. It certainly doesn’t stop me from coming in to get by far the best bagel around speedy service with a smile. Wonderful spot, thanks for all that you do!

Bagels are great, people are nice, place is clean and beautiful. Shame on the people leaving 1-star reviews, this is not a 1-star business... wish I could respond to those people, what a bunch of whiney losers. These are the best bagels in Newburgh and nobody has ever been rude to me there, nor has the wait been too long.

This is a reason this places get awesome reviews! I love the breakfast wraps, when you ask for avocado on it, they actually give you a lot! They have