Harleys American Grille - Farmingdale

Very loud, had to scream. Eating was cut, was much better 2 years ago, but they changed domething. also expensive. it was already for brunch, which was very loud, but eating was excellent.

Food and service were very good. Will definitely be going back

Perhaps this was an off night for the place, This was my 3rd time dining at Harleys. We brought our visiting family from out of town with us, a party of 6 which includes 2 children. Two of the 4 cocktails that came out were wrong, with waitress apologizing that regular bartender was off so manager filled in. The replacement drinks were fine. Kids hamburgers were beyond well done, a couple of bites and they ate only fries. My shrimp cocktail was delivered on bed of ice with a few strands of seaweed, no cocktail sauce, so I had to track down someone to bring it. It didn’t appear to be an especially busy night but adult entrees were delivered almost 90 minute after seating. My shaved steak sandwich looked good on the plate but after struggling to bite into it, I had to pass. It was like tearing into leather. Seriously, I do t know how a kitchen could pass this off as a shaved steak sandwich. It was awful. My guests were not thrilled with their entrees mentioning that theirs were overcooked as well. I expressed my displeasure with the waitresses and gave her the feedback she wanted to pass on. When the bill came, she comped us several cocktails and took off my entree. To top off the evening, the restaurants fire alarm sounded, people continued to eat unbothered as the fire department was on their way. For us, after paying bill, we couldn’t get out fast enough.

Great service great food. Happy we stopped in. Look forward to going back.

The restaurant is very pretty. Understanding that we were there Xmas eve, we did have to ask three times to get sodas and never got water refills. There were four of us dining. We ordered apps and meals. The brought the apps and one meal all at the same time. Then we waited for the other three meals. I asked for well done tuna and it was seared at best. I specifically asked for not rare. For dessert we ordered zeppoles which were very heavy and not so tasty. But we ordered two portions. The portions were huge and could feed ten. The waiter asked us why we ordered two! It’s his job to tell us it was too much. I had to take forks off the next table as the meal was served and my son had no utensils. The artichoke salad was over fried and scratchy when eating. The coffee cup was tiny and no room to loop in fingers and no one ever asked about refills. Finally we get the bill and the pen didn’t write! Overall disappointment