Tellers An American Chophouse - Islip

We sat immediately and the staff was very attentive to our needs and really explained in detail and questions we might have had. Food from appetizers to dessert was excellent. Fresh, hot and very tasteful. Overall, it was an amazing experience and will definitely come back.

We came here for our 5th anniversary and had such a great time. We ordered the filet mignon and it was delicious! We also had the scalculed potatoes and creamy spinach and you can not go wrong with it. We had cocktails and deserts. Our waiter was fabulous and overall we had a great night. That was our third time we came to plates and every time we had a great experience. We'll be back here.

We celebrated our 5th anniversary. Everybody was great. I had the Sirloin stripe and she had the fillet and lobster tail, the accessories (sides) were enough for two, we got grilled asparagus and percussion potatoes, and dessert we had the cream brûlée. Everything was amazing, didn't feel like we were rushed through everything, like other places that feel you. Thanks again.

Not fond of the forest mushrooms with the salmon. Bring back the old way.

The Filet Mignon Wellington was exceptional. The vegetable sides perfect.