Rotten City Pizza - Feedback

Really good pizza except ridiculously overpriced! The same if not better pizza at Nick‘s Pizza for More than half the price many options! New York style at RC b...

Sorry for the low rating. I had pizza delivered from there to Wondrous brewing yesterday. The quality has declined significantly since I last ate there 5-6 year...

The food is not bad, but it’s way overpriced. A friend and I got a pizza, no drinks, and it was almost $50 with tip. The back seating area was kind of a mess, W...

I hate to give a bad review...but to charge $49 for one pizza? $14 for one slice of plain cheese pizza? $20 for a small plastic container of salad? It would be...

Honestly, insulting for the customer, the workers, and the owner. My partner and I got a slice of cheese (not standard on this menu so check to make sure you di...

Great piece pizza. they gave me a great beer recommendation and then told me how to get into the actual brewery!

Fantastic pizza. lived here 12 years and this is just jumped into my top 5. on real NY pizza in long island, so I got registration information lol

Not the biggest location, but this place is defined a contagious high bar for NY style pizza. Perfect taste on the crust, only the correct amount of fat, this p...

I love rotten city pizza! I was always here and then when I left, I was super cheated because no other pizza place could even come close. the pizza is just as d...

Perfect new york style pizza! From the texture of the dough, the texture of the cheese, the greasiness of it, the crust on the edges, everything was spot on and...

A fantastic gentleman arrived 40 minutes late and kindly offered us discounted leftovers. 10/10 would definitely recommend.

We arrived at the restaurant near closing time (apologies to the staff) and ordered a half pizza that was not listed on the menu. However, the staff not only ac...

When I say I eat here a lot, I mean I eat here a LOT. You won 't find low quality ingredients, and you will probably be surprised by the size of a Slice it 's a...

That meatball sandwich is worth it. They have a great selection of beer too.

This place is fantastic! The meatball sub was absolutely delicious and had a nice, moist, and hot pocket of meat.

Still great! Decided on splitting a meatball sub with my partner. We ordered it, a beer, and they gave us a day-old brownie. The meatball sub was hot and...

Pizza place with alcohol. Definitely not a place for cocktails but they will serve you shots if you want. Decent beer selection. Go across the street to...

This pizza is amazing!! My team gets it for lunch all the time, they have great toppings options! Super friendly service, they are always happy to serve...