Papaseverius - Elgin

Three strikes and they 're out! Just moved into town. Was craving a calzone. We found this place and ordered. Calzone, chicken alfredo for the 11 year old, and meatballs for the Keto wife. Calzone was amazing and packed full of the goodies and blew my mind. Alfredo was great too. However we have realized it was a fluke. Read on.... Second try, expecting the same as first order. Nope. Alfredo was not linguini this time, calzone was like dough and barely sprinkled with the ingredients. Disappointing and weird but not a show stopper. Third attempt: Getting worse. Wife ordered meatballs and gets a call from the food delivery guy at pickup that they are out of meatballs and asked for a substitute. No call from restaurant when they read the order? Wow! This time the calzone was still doughy even though we said we 'll done because of previous failure. Calzone was almost empty again. No red sauce for the calzone this time. We tried chicken strips with bbq sauce on the side for the kids since we didn 't know what to expect from chicken alfredo....the strips looked like they dumped a bowl of bbq sauce on them and wasn 't even covering them all. We gave them three chances cause we wanted to love them like we did the first time we ordered but strike three....never again.

So far I have had the had the combo sandwich and pizza by slice $4) and both were really good!

Omg this guy is so mean, rude and racist. My friend who is white, likes getting pizza by the slice here and he is always nice to him. I came in here being not white, asked for a slice he said he didn 't have any. MY friend had just been there and said they had some. What you sell out that fast? I also witnessed him say Of course you want grape soda under his breath about a black customer. If you 're white, you are welcomed. If not don 't even bother. Anyways my friend says the pizza is ok.

Do not eat the food here! I was waiting for an order so had plenty of time to watch what was going on here. The man at the counter was answering the phone and taking orders. He would then walk in the kitchen and make the pizza, he did not wear a mask or gloves, nor did he ever wash his hands. He had his hands in the various containers holding the ingredients that he was putting on the pizzas. Then he would answer the phone and go back to the pizza. It was the most disgusting thing to watch. I'm pretty sure this is against health code even if we weren't in a coronavirus pandemic! This place was so gross!

Ordered a pizza. When it was delivered the driver could not figure out where to deliver. He called but I was unable to answer. I did eventually answer and then the driver demanded to know why I wasn 't answering. Unprofessional and rude. But I understood the frustration and even apologized. Upon delivery I said nothing and the driver said What are you looking at? Completely unprofessional and disgusting behavior. First and last time ordering. Good job.