Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza Commack

The pizza was very good and the service was friendly and accommodating. The seats we were in could have used a little extra attention to the cleaning after the last guests.

Honestly, the meatball and ricotta pizza and italian salad were good. But the service and cleanliness were not good at all. Don't think I will go there again, unless maybe to take out.

Consistent quality is what brings us back to Anthony's. Chicken wings can't be beat and we enjoy the variety of pizzas. Start with the house salad and you can't go wrong!

When I arrived they told me they did not have a reservation for me and do not take reservations. There was a line of people and my time was limited due to another obligation later that evening. The hostess was great and made sure she cleared a table right away and gave us priority seating. We were at a table within 5 minutes. Food and service were good.

The food was standard for Anthony’s, however the restaurant was very dirty. Tables and chairs were sticky and there was food scattered all over the floor.