Mill Creek Tavern - Feedback

I had a lobster roll which was pretty disappointing. There were no actual chunks of lobster. It just seemed like scraps from other lobsters

A local gem. Cozy and warm. Great bar (where we normally park). Great food. Great service.

My wife,daughter and her friend took me to Mill Creek for a Fathers Day dinner.We all had the special the girls had lobster and I had a steak and the entire mea...

Our waiter, a man with longer, curly hair and facial hair during the Sunday 6/9/24 at 5pm shift) was attentive and kind. The restaurant’s ambiance was relaxing...

The food is always outstanding there but this mid week menu is awesome Also, our server Vanessa makes you feel like she’s entertaining you in her living room Ex...

We had a great family dinner at Mill Creek! The Pierogis appetizer was delicious! My salmon, one of the specials was delicious, served with a zucchini pancake y...

Always a great meal and service! A sweetheart for good reason

I'm from the south coast for 30 minutes. I'm always happy with the food and the service is top notch. It is also a beautiful place in the city walking around. A...

Delicious food and welcoming staff and great service

Always great! Food and service are exceptional. Fresh ingredients cooked perfectly.

This place is an absolute gem. Got a surprise when I got there and realized it was happy hour, so I got half priced appetizer which I had as my meal. That...

Made a reservation here for restaurant week. Apparently didn't need one. The place has its own parking lot with about a dozen spots. We entered the building...

Came here to celebrate a friend's birthday. Great wine and a fantastic meal made the celebration with good friends the perfect night. The place is not too...

This review is for yelp I don't like what you do my yelp reviews go to where it doesn't count that's how you treat me I don't like I won't use yelp any more I r...

I went to a baby shower there. I dont know about these Yelp events? The restaurant is divided into three sections. The first is the bar, The there is bar seatin...

We started with the crab cakes as an appetizer, and they were fantastic! They may not always be available, but if they are a special, they are a must-try. My hu...

Our server was fabulous. We had a great time and food was delicious.

Felt like a cozy place to have dinner and relax will come again

We frequent Mill Creek with our three young kiddos, and the food and ambience is always 5 star status!

The hostess was impolite and we ordered three fried chicken sandwiches, all of which were very dry. This place is inconsistent in its quality.

The food and the environment at Mill Creek are both incredible! The staff is always super friendly and Rich, the owner, is often there greeting people, checking...

Sort ribs in Jaegerschnitzel sauce was amazing, perhaps my best meal here. Really nice go to neighborhood gem.

Great food and great service for couples and large groups. And I can’t say enough about the waitress.

The bartenders are the best especially Kathy Pirkl. The food is always excellent. Very comfortable and great ambiance.

Excellent staff. Duck was crispy delicious, sauce was perfect. Special seasonal salad was very flavorful. Everyone in our group had something different all were...

This is a great little local spot. We always liked getting the chicken pot pie during the cold season. It is absolutely the best chicken pot pie you will ever h...

Scott is the best bartender everr!!! Go Scott he was so welcoming sweet Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Food: 4 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Wow the food was just amazing. Complete comfort food vibes.. everything made with love and freah Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Rec...

The food is always exceptional and the atmosphere is very warm and comforting. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Food service was excellant! Staff is excellent as well!! Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommende...

My favorite go-2 resturant in Bayville, NY. Not only is the food excellent (haven?t still had a bad meal), but the staff is friendly and professional. Richard,...

Love this place! The food is so good, the menu varies. We try to order a new thing every time we go, but it's hard not to get the pork chops and the sliders!!

A tavern with a dining room off to the side. This is a strange layout. You enter the tavern, that smells like a tavern shuffle past the barflies to stand in the...

My wife and I had a great, relaxing dinner here. The food was awesome, the inside of the restaurant is nice and cozy, and the service was fantastic and everyone...

We were visiting family in Mill neck and choose Mill Creek Tavern because they have a very nice menu. I like that they print the daily specials with description...