Toomey's Tavern - Amityville

My husband and I went to toomeys the past 2 fridays. It is so nice on the water and the bands are entertaining. Tonight we ordered 2 buckets of corona. On the menu, it lists buckets $25 for domestic $30 for imported. On the bill it said 2 buckets= $70. I asked the waitress and she said it is $35 each when there is a band. If that is the case, they should have a different menu they hand out when they have a band or it should be noted that the price goes up. We didn't really need the 2nd bucket. I only had 1 beer from each and we actually had 1 we didn't even touch. I think it will be a while before I return bc being charged more than what is printed on the menu really left a bad taste in my mouth.

Cute neighborhood gem, as long as you know what to expect you're good. Not fancy, very laid back and casual. This is def a spot for the locals reasonably priced and best visited in the warmer months, when you can grab a table on the back deck overlooking the canal

Awesome food, great ambiance and the drinks are on point! Staff was super friendly and overall great experience.

Had lunch with friends very good service and food. will definately return very nice for a dive bar.

A band we follow played here yesterday from 4 through 8 pm, so we thought we'd stop by for dinner, drinks, and great music. Fivestone played excellent music, but we did not have dinner. Why? Because the hostess refused to seat us outdoors near the band because we were too small of a party (2), but she said we could be seated in the enclosed tent in the back, where we could not really hear the band nor dance. We bought some drinks and enjoyed the band but started noticing a couple sitting at Table 21 and not eating, two people being led to Table 24 by the hostess, and another couple just strolling in and seating themselves at Table 29. Meanwhile, we had to stand the entire time. Judging by many of the other comments regarding food and service, we're glad we did not have dinner here that night. To be sure, we will never return.