Gaetano's Grill

Called to place an order, what I was charged and what the menu states is included is completely different. And it says “new menu” on the website ??‍. Then the pizza arrived and the cheese with sliding off and the entire pizza was legitimately just cheese, where’s the sauce!??? I haven’t ordered here in about 2 years because the service and food hasn’t been great but I took a shot this evening and will not be making the mistake again.

I used to love this place. It was my absolute favorite pizza spot in the area. My fiancé and I were ordering from there every week. Then they double charged me due to a computer error and despite several visits to explain what happened they never made good on the extra $50 that I was charged. It took a while to find a new pizza spot but now I’m giving my pizza money to Forno’s on Welcher Ave in Peekskill.

Very nice, attentive staff. Good pizza. Family friendly. Definitely will be back.

I’ve tried time and time again to give this place a chance. Their problem is lack of consistency and effort. Immediately you can tell when walking in all their house pies are days old until they’re completely sold in order to make fresh ones. I typically order a wood fired margarita pie from here and when it’s good… it’s good. When it’s terrible I regret my decision going there. They charge top dollar for sup par food. The last pizza I ordered weighed about 5lbs and had giant chunks of tomatoes under the cheese so it all slid off. My last time going.

Food was amazing and portions were generous. Service was mediocre. Facilities we're atrociously bad. Please clean and fix the leak in the restrooms!