Jersey Mike's Subs - Town of Newburgh

DO NOT EAT HERE UNLESS YOU WANT FOOD POISONING!!!! Place is FILTHY, the workers are beyond rude. We ordered 4 sandwiches today from this location and not a single one was edible. Bread hard as a hockey puck, slimy old tasting cold cuts and sour old tasting bacon. Never again. Please don’t spend your hard earned money here!

Had a truly pleasant experience here. The guy who took my order and also made the sandwich was professional, polite, checked to make sure I was certain of order and said goodbye is a way that I felt good walking out. His service alone would make me want to revisit this location!

First time made a gr8 impression...will be back...scrumptious.

Gross and unsafe food handling practices. Whoever is the owner or manager seriously needs to go over with their staff the proper procedures when it comes to handling food. Like taking off their gloves when they handle money or maybe not keeping the knife they use to cut food by the register. The sad part is that the staff clearly do not care. If theyre willing to do those things in front of customers then what are they doing when there arent any customers around..

I wish they were friendlier, changed their gloves and wore their hair in a cap. I felt intimidated and rushed, watch them handle bags, register and food without changing their gloves and came home to a sandwich with hair in it.