The Bay Street - Feedback

Very disappointing. Heard good things thought would have drinks and dinner. Bartender complained nonstop from the time we walked in and made us feel so unwelcom...

This place is a rather nondescript and hidden gem. The doors are a bit crooked and so are the floors but that simply adds to the charm. The service was excellen...

The most extensive list and best made cocktail around. Steaks and seafood dishes are top notch, too.

Dinner was excellent as always. Had sea bass. One definitely could improve the experience: I would suggest to post the martini menu online. With over 100 martin...

We found this hidden gem a few years ago. Loved the food and the ambience. It changed ownership a couple of years ago. Then covid hit. Tonight being our anniver...

Went for drinks...fun place and staff pretty friendly. Meal type: Other Price per person: $10–20 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4

Cool place, especially cocktails, a little on the pricey side but delicious. Food is good and a little pricey as well, but worth it nonetheless. Service: Dine i...

4 of us visited for the 1st time Friday at 5:30. We had the crab cake appetizers, the full filet, Bay Street Shrimp, stuffed pork chop, and lobster mac and chee...

This is a top-notch restaurant with a unique charm. While the seating and menu options are limited, I have never had a meal that wasn't absolutely delicious. Th...

The meal was excellent, but the restaurant could use some renovations. The menu is limited and although they advertise an extensive martini list, you have to sp...

Great food and drink. Friendly and knowledgeable staff. A must if you visit Sodus Point. A diamond in the ruff.

We miss the old Bay Street. the eclectic decor is the same, the martini book is still there but the atmosphere and the spirit is gone. What a shame. We used to...

Always outstanding. Bay Street is a guaranteed great experience, not just a meal. You start with an extensive offering of martinis and Manhattans complimented b...

Excellent service, food cooked to perfection. Atmosphere is wonderful, we will go here a couple times a year, and are never disappointed

The potatoes and corn were lukewarm and tasted like reheated leftovers. This was not a pleasant experience considering the high price of the entrees ($80 each)....