Antonio's Real New York Pizza

I'll start off by saying that the pizza we bought was a very good pie! The crust was crispy and had very good flavor. I do think they skimped on the Pepperonis and what we ordered was different than what we got. If the review was based solely on the Pizza I may have given this a 4 star review. The sides were not so good.....we went with the Garlic Knots and house salads and they were decent but you could tell that the knots were simply thrown together, maybe even frozen, but they left me regretting my order. The salad was okay, but the bell peppers on it were old and discolored. The exterior of the restaurant was cool, but the interior was old, outdated and could afford to have some money invested back in to it. Definitely has potential, but it needs some better marketing behind it. Was it a good pie? Yes! Would I go back? Definitely not. 2 stars due to my follow up experience after my review, I would've expected professionalism.

The pizza was very good. Perfect thin crust, airy with just the right crunch. The service from Milica was exceptional, as it was from all of the employees. My grandchildren thought the half pepperoni half cheese pizza was delicious. I took Milica’s advice and had the White Garlic with roasted chicken and am glad I did. We all loved the robot delivery cart. The management is doing everything right. I live in Northern Colorado and will be telling my family and friends about this Estes Park gem. Kid-friendliness: Grandkids said, “Really good pizza”. Robot table side delivery was cool. Our server, Milica, engaged the kids in a friendly and helpful manner.

This was the best pizza ever. The wait staff was great. We had the Detroit Red Top Pizza. The price was good for the area too and just overall in general too. I would definitely go back.

Our server Milicia was oustanding! She is very knowledgable about the menu and gave excellent detailed recommendations.

Great Pizza and Quality toppings! It was Saturday night and they were slammed. We got our food to go...Large Godfather pizza and an order of 5 Sweet Baby Ray wings. It took about an hour to get our order...it's tough to be patient when you are hungry! It was worth the wait!! The pizza was great and the wings were really good though, the wings were plain...no Baby Ray sauce). Be patient my friends, plan ahead if you can.