Mystic Meat Seafood Market

I’ve come to this establishment twice. The first time in 2022 I was so impressed with the quality and flavor of the lobster roll. This summer it was bland and quite possibly smaller.

This was our first time ordering from Mystic Market LBI and it won 't be our last. It is very clean and bright inside, with a few tables if you want to sit and eat, and it 's conveniently located on Long Beach Blvd in Ship Bottom. We ordered a large Italian sub and a mighty Maine lobster roll. Both were huge, fresh, and delicious!

Food was a bit pricey, frozen lobster tail was 15.99/lb when I could buy a live lobster at shoprite for 8.99/lb this late in summer. They also did not have some things like scallops but that’s because they only come in on certain days. I will say this, while the selection is not priced competitively and stock is hit or miss the quality of the seafood and steaks is very high. I probably would not stop by here again unless I was looking for something particular, but if you don’t mind the prices they do sell quality food.

Lobster rolls were wonderful, had the Connecticut version. Many selections to choose from, cold with mayo to hot with butter, you name it, they had it. The roll came with cole slaw and a pickle. We shared fries, did not order drinks (although there was a large assortment). Bill was $50.

Delicious lobster roll, clean market, very friendly staff. It's exactly what you want in a lobster roll, meaty with a nice sweet bun. Would definitely recommend