Shelter Island Slice - Feedback

From a native, this place just opened during COVID-19 and it is worth trying. four of us have enjoyed our meal and will definitely go back! everyone table.

Pizza was good, nothing very special, but good. the dough is on the chewing gum (not dry side and overall I would advise the cake 8. the salate is fantastic.

Only place on the island to get pizza, and without reason it should not stay like that! from the teig to the cheese to the sauce it is a delicious pizza in NY s...

The pizza is amazing and frankie makes more for common than anyone I know!

Frankie personal always super friendly, eating is always worth the trip from sag harbor

Nice place to relax, friendly service and delicious food. 5/5/5 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Great pizza and awesome staff. Would go back Service: Dine in Meal type: Other Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4

The best pizza on Long Island. Eat in this nice clean space with a big tv for games. Friendly staff and reasonable prices. Love this crust so much; you’ll be a...

11/10 customer service, these guys are great. I come here on a weekly basis and I've only ever had positive experiences here. Everything I've tried from here is...

You won't find better pizza period Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Chicken Bacon...

When ever I drive through even if I’m not hungry I have to grab a I always grab a slice. Great pizza!

Look no further if you're in search of excellent pizza. Shelter Island Slice has been my favorite since I was a child, even surpassing the famed pizza in New Ha...

The pizza is fantastic at this restaurant, but it is always bustling with customers. I try to ignore the odd and aggressive behavior of the owner towards anyone...

The customer service at this restaurant is outstanding, I would give it 11 out of 10! I visit this place weekly and every experience has been positive. Everythi...

Frankie still makes the best pizza in the area by far.

Very good pizza. Gcallous. Service and people. Wish they made calzons.

Pizza is amazing and the same can be said about the staff

Was doing work out there and this guy had it all great spot great pizza great service ???? cold ????

Needed an ole school pizza joint. Easy ,beer ,soda, pizza n Italian sandwiches. Non complicated n nice friendly workers

Fast, delicious, and family friendly

Although a bit pricey, the pies are all freshly made with fresh ingredients. Everyone who works here is friendly and welcoming. A great option on the island!

Very friendly staff and spacious indoor seating at this restaurant. The chicken bacon ranch slice is loaded with toppings which was delicious and super filling....