Joey's Custard - Feedback

After a bad experience with unfriendly employees somewhere on the island, we decided to give this place an attempt. We were very pleasantly surprised. Friendly...

Had the pleasure of finally getting out to Joeys with the family today. I have to say it was an awesome experience starting with the great atmosphere and the fo...

Wide selection of ice creams, custards and sorbets with an endless variety of ways to eat them! Staff were super friendly and patient as everyone came in and sp...

The soft serve ice cream is delicious! Nice size serving and awesome toppings. The staff was very friendly and they were open late (at least for the island). Th...

Local Army Veteran, family owned, Nice guy! We met Joey while on vacation. What a really great guy! They have delicious ice cream! My favorite was Salted Carame...

Amazing! We were on Sanibel for a family holiday for a week. I swear we drove five times! We also brought all our visitors. The orange Crunch Cake Custard mixtu...

We visited Joey's Custard while on vacation in June. It was clear it is an island favorite given the line and energy! The line moved fast, the variety of option...

Joey's is an amazing family ice cream shop on Sanibel, in the Bailey's Shopping Plaza. The flavours are amazing, mixing traditional with Sanibel Specialties lik...

Or make this dinner instead. We have had Joey’s for dinner several times during our Sanibel vacations. Best staff, best selections (sooo many! , best ingredient...

The custard is so good that my hubby and friends would go there often twice a day on bikes. They would try something new each time and were never disappointed,...

House made ice with a minimum of two vegan aromen at any time as well as other vegan options such as fruit skins. the products are made fresh every week and eve...

By far the best ice cream you could ever have. I work on Sanibel and go to his shop at lunch breaks and after work! The staff is so sweet and helpful. Joey cate...

Great find on an island with not many vegan options. Loved the ice cream. We both got soy based cookies and cream but they had one other soy based flavor and se...

After a beach day, an ice cream is a MUST! Joeys was the perfect place. Had vegan sorbets, ices, and ice creams. Ice cream changes every so often so there isn’t...

Had a few flavors when I went- vanilla chip and peach. Also had ices that were vegan! Great to go to after Sanibel Sprouts (next door)

Amazing! We were on Sanibel for a family vacation for a week. I swear we went 5 times! We brought all our visitors as well. The orange crunch cake custard mix w...

Love Joey’s custard! Huge variety of flavors and WI, Chocolate Shoppe ice cream too!! The staff is Amazing as well! Or favorite Sweet treat stop when we visit S...

If I could give this place more stars, I absolutely would! My family and I have been visiting Sanibel for over 50 years, and it wasn't until last summer that we...

I absolutely love this place! The atmosphere is fantastic, the staff is friendly, and their custard is delicious! I’m eagerly looking forward to their reopening...

Joey's is one of the best ice cream shops around. They will rise again. #sanibelstrong

Love this place. Great selection. Staff is polite and very helpful. Definitely going back once they are open again

The bridge tolls are currently waived on Sundays to encourage visitors to support businesses on Sanibel and Captiva Island. My motorcycle group visited there th...

This charming ice cream, shake, malt, and candy shop brings back nostalgic vibes. The place is spotless, and the owners and staff are incredibly friendly. The d...

The service was outstanding, and the custard was fantastic. The restaurant is also accessible for individuals with disabilities. You can select your flavor and...