Mtk Lobster House Sag Harbor

I see a lot of bad reviews, I personally had a wonderful experience the one time I have tried this place. I thought the shrimp quesadillas were delicious and ordered extra sauces which were also delicious. The service was great and I plan to go back andtry some other items on the menu. Update: back this season and have been here twice. My experience continues to be positive. Thewait staff is Wonderful, every meal I have ordered is delicious.

We reluctantly decided to eat here after getting turned away at every other restaurant in the immediate area (the poor reviews and relatively empty restaurant behind our reluctance). That said, we had a really nice meal and attentive, good service. I hada martini that was respectable (which is too often not the case) and oysters which were good (not great). The lobster roll wasexcellent and the Mexican spice mussels was delicious. Our daughter had the pesto pasta with grilled shrimp which was flavorfuland perfectly cooked. Admittedly, we went in with low expectations but having eaten at pretty much every restaurant in Sag, onthis given night MTK Lobster held its own. We will be going back.

Their website explained that were opened. opentable allowed me to make a reservation. drove all the way from greenport for this reservation with the family, and the restaurant never opened. ridiculous. update their website, they do not allow reservations if it is not open, no their task as restaurant owners. nonsense.

Very warm and welcoming. nice vibe. pasta dish, although tasty, was extremely overpriced given the portion size. I was also calculated $2 extra for Tito’s on a vodka drink, although it is not a “premier” wodka. that was ridiculous, I will certainly come back, as my visits were always edible here, but they should consider my comments

Food and service were average. I had an eating card and they refused to honour the discount!