Feil's Supper Club - Randolph

A group of five had a five course meal. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes: Fresh Salad Bar, Large Salad Bar, Haystack Onion Rings, Onion Rye Bread, Feils Famous Onion Rings, German Potato Salad

Feil's Supper Club is an awesome supper club with German focus. They have a beer garden and often have live polka. They have a decent beer menu and the bar tenders make great drinks, especially the ice cream drinks after dinner. Feil's has an awesome salad bar. They have lots of toppings, pasta salads, cottage cheese, cheese dips, liver paste, soups, etc. On our last stop the chicken and stuffed shrimp were great. Our friends got the German buffet. The service is very friendly, we have been here a few times and will be back again.

Growing up in northern WI, Supper Clubs were the places to go. Moving down to central WI and 40 years later when Supper Clubs are no longer common, finding this gem Fiels is like going home. Coming from a Polish/German household, to step into Fiels is like a blast from the past. The food is absolutely fantastic, everything Fiels has to offer I highly recommend. If you have never had German dishes, don't be leery, at least try it, you will be amazed. Home made (reminded me so much of growing up), a true Supper Club, you will not leave hungry and you will reluctantly leave very satisfied. The staff is personable, friendly and amazing. Drinks are big and you will have one of the best Old Fashion that WI has to offer. Our state cocktail. Joann is absolutely wonderful, I could spend hours talking to her. The gem in the middle of farmland. Fiels is just a mile or so easy of Randolph on Hwy. 73. Look for the German chalet, go in, have a great time in a true Supper Club with the bonus of having German dishes, specials, their celebration of Oktoberfest, wonderful, friendly staff, Joann who is fantastic, home made food, great cocktails and bartenders who are so friendly and not shy with the liquor and an overall atmosphere that makes you feel at home and is hard to leave. Have fun and Gemutlichkeit!!

Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 4 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Fresh Salad Bar

I've always wanted to try this restaurant, and a few months ago, we finally went for dinner with another couple. Unfortunately, we weren't greeted in the warm way we expected, and we all felt the service was rather brusque throughout the evening. None of us were rude or drinking alcohol, so it's unclear why the staff seemed unfriendly toward us. We did notice that well-known patrons received quite different treatment. The salad bar was good, and our meal was decent, though nothing exceptional. I hope to give them another chance to see what the hype is about and to maybe receive a warmer welcome.