The Captain's Table - Punta Gorda Isles

I wish I could give this 5 stars. We walked in and there was a host, Kamar, and a hostess, Nora. We had reservations and Kamar was ready to sit us. He was very polite and professional. Nora came in a stopped the whole thing. Very rude and unprofessional. Told us were not ready to seat you even though it was 6/1/23 at 6pm and the place was empty. We went to go wait outside downstairs. About 20 minutes later a waitress named Cindy comes to the rescue and tells us to get back inside. Kamar and Cindy took us to our table. Service was excellent. Food was delicious. Very professional. I will definitely come back and try again. Definitely recommend this place to anyone. I don't want one unhappy person to ruin the whole experience. Nora comes back at the end and asked how our dinner was and she was happy to see us. Yeah okay.

Have been coming here for years. Stopped in for a drink in December and just getting a chance to write this review. Ordered a martini and a beer. The bartender was clueless. She put vodka into a glass but let it sit for more than 10 minutes with ice. She then strained the ice and the vodka into a another martini glass. The result? A martini so watered down it had to be returned. The bartender exhibited extremely poor organization and time management. I also ordered a craft beer. I We all know that some craft beer is poured i. smaller quantity due to the amount of alcohol or brand; however, the amount in the pour I received differed from other pours of the same beer. My allocation was not even 2/3 of the glass. I asked the bartender top it up. Her response was that that’s all I should be getting. I asked her why I was only receiving a shorted 10 ounce pour yet she was pouring the same beer, topping off full pint glasses to give to the waitresses. This made her angry, so she topped off my 10 ounce glass with some foam!!! One of the first times in my life, I didn’t leave a tip. After the thousands and thousands of dollars that I’ve spent at this restaurant, only to come back and experience this type of terrible customer service…they’ve lost me forever.

Excellent restaurant! Food, service, atmosphere and great company made for a perfect experience. Everything was cooked to perfection, and we all raved about our choices. You can't go wrong here!

No umbrellas for our side tables. And a few tables in the second level in the Shade! But a Very nice view overlooking the water and boats. Bar like atmosphere down stairs! I liked the seat yourself policy. The waitress was excellent and she couldn't have been nicer.

Recently visited on a trip to Florida. Definitely exceeded our expectations. Our server, Kayla, I think, was great and very attentive. We had margaritas to drink, started with coconut shrimp zucchini fries, both were delicious. My sister i had steak and my other sister had fish. Everything was delicious, fresh and cooked perfectly. We sat outside overlooking the water which enhanced our experience. Will definitely return.