Noah's Pizza - Pewaukee

This was our first time ordering from this restaurant and we decided to try a couple of pizzas. It was a delicious experience! Typically, we order extra cheese on our pizzas, but it wasn't necessary here. The pizzas had plentiful toppings, great sauce, and an awesome thin crust. We ended up ordering too much food, but it will make for leftovers. The delivery time was originally set for 7:37pm, but they arrived at our door at 7:07pm. We think we have found our new go-to pizza place! Thank you! Unfortunately, our second order did not go as well. While the pizza was still good, it had been dropped on its side, making it difficult to pick out the slices. Additionally, the jumbo shrimp meal was missing half of the shrimp and was substituted with some sort of fish without our knowledge. Overall, we were not impressed with this experience.

We have discovered our new favorite pizza spot! After receiving a coupon for Noah's in the mail, we decided to give it a shot. It only took one bite for us to fall in love with their delicious pizza and cheesy garlic bread. We highly recommend trying them out!

As the reviews indicate, this is either a love-it or hate-it style of pizza. I?ll just add a photo of ours- if this looks like your kind of pizza, you?re in luck :

Ordered online for a 3 pm pickup. Got there at 3 pm?was informed they forgot. Told me to wait 10 minutes. Very apologetic. Pizza was good.

Picked up dinner for myself and my daughter's family. The antipasto was fresh and excellent! I also purchased the chimichanga dinner and 2 Italian dinners. So much food for $46!! It was also ready at the time stated. So glad to have this business near by.