Old Chicago Pizza - Petaluma

Usually my favorite pizza in the world but I guess everyone has an of night. The pizza was overdone to the point of being partially burned. Didn't complain because it takes so long to cook the deep dish but definitely disappointed with crust to hard and dark to enjoy that part... Both upper or crust and bottom crust were affected. Still, the main body of the poor was edible. Service was fine but nothing special.

It’s sad my family has be eating at this place for over 30 yrs I called to make a pickup order and was told I couldn’t make the order because I didn’t have a card to place the order after being told they do not take orders after 8:30 pm but if I had a card they would have placed the order after explaining to them that I am driving about two hrs away and would be arriving at 9 pm … I was then told if I had a card they would … just found it crazy I wonder how much money and customs the business loses out on because of this kind of customer service… rant over the food is still good …

Food was great and service was good! Atmosphere was a bit loud but otherwise it was a good time! Have also had good luck playing games while eating at this restaurant

Really good place to have a last minute birthday dinner. They can accommodate a fairly large party(we had 10) in a short time frame. It’s the go to place in Petaluma for deep dish pizza.

Sorry didn’t take a picture I was too hungry and my double crust sausage and olive was so good!!!