New Yorker Pizza - Petaluma

ABSOLUTELY LOVED IT! We were trying to decide where to eat dinner while we visited Downtown Petaluma and parked right in front of the restaurant. We were so impressed with the home cooked meals we received, it has this welcome feeling and old fashioned atmosphere that is hard to find nowadays. We recommend it 100% and you can bet we're coming back again and bringing out acquaintances. Thank you New Yorker Pizza

Great little place. I had linguine with garlic and clams and it was delicious. Definitely enough for two meals which I'm looking forward to eating tomorrow. The garlic bread is also very good

When my child decided he was so hungry he wanted to eat his takeout pizza right there in the over-priced pizza restaurant, the proprieter was so incredibly petty she complained loudly that we used the takeout box (which I knew we would use anyway and we did), wouldn't serve me the water I asked for, and she took back the bill and charged us the eat-in tax instead of the take-out tax. And when she did, she charged us for a third pizza we did not order and I nearly fell for it and paid until my kid noticed. This place is ridiculously over-priced, it was nearly $20 for a low-quality mini pizza. No wonder there was nobody else in the place. There are so many better pizza places in Petaluma. We won't be coming back.

Great place, for pizza or pasta. Low key and great staff

It was a bit uncomfortable having to wait more than 45 minutes for my order but it was worth it