Cafe Rinaldi - Old Forge

Very good Italian food. Pasta was delicious. I definitely recommend. Will be back..

Best risotto ever ! The desserts and pizza and chicken Marsala are good too ! Such great Italian food a staple in old forge !

Tough not giving this place 5 stars because the food was really good. If you want really good Italian food then this is a good place to go, however you need to be prepared for a few things 1. Not that big of a deal for me, but the wine list is lacking. Cavit, Woodbridge… I don’t remember the rest but they were all bottom of the shelf. 2. This one really threw me over the edge, to the point where I really don’t think I’ll go back. Most items on the menu are around $20. They had a lobster special for the night, it was our anniversary so I wasn’t really worried about the price, I figured as long as it’s good paying MKT price (which I thought would be south of $50) wouldn’t be that big of a deal. When I got the bill the lobster was $80! And it wasn’t a whole lobster, just the tail. Now I realize that spiny lobsters don’t have claws but for $80 I’d at least expect a cold water lobster. and because my wife wanted gnocchi it was and extra $10. So I spent $90 on lobster tail and pasta. I just felt price gouged. I’m not here to trash the place. It’s been around forever, they have a good product, but $80 for a lobster tail is overstepping.

This is a delicious Italian restaurant located on Main Street. Every dish in the place is amazing. Friendly staff, great drinks, and plenty of seating. Whether your looking to dine in or take out you can't go wrong, just bring your

Went for a birthday dinner. Not an extensive menu but good choices with pasta, chicken and veal. Portions are huge. Next time may opt for a side order of pasta with meatballs. Nice atmosphere and great attentive service. Don’t forget to make reservations because you won’t get a seat.