Mary Jane's Dairy - Newburgh

This morning my mother asked for two different flavors of ice cream from Mary Jane's. I messaged them and to my surprise, they answered right away. One flavor butter pecan) they make. The other request, orange and vanilla swirl) they don't. They had an incredible suggestion. Half orange sherbet and half soft vanilla. They put each half long ways down the container so she would have some of both with each scoop. It was ready for pickup. I couldn't be more pleased and my mother is delighted. Thank you for such great customer service.

I am rarely brave enough to try a veggie burger I don't know, but this one came recommended. And it was yummy! Vegetarians: Know you've got a great option at Mary Jane's. (I recommend getting it topped with the grilled onions.

Amazing HOMEMADE ice cream. Great owner and friendly staff. It's a landmark for this area.

So many choices! The attention to detail, warm, friendly staff, DELICIOUS ice cream...just a few of the things that make MaryJane's a five star establishment!!

The lemon ice cream is amazing we loved it. So creamy and fresh