Brooklyn Pizza - Newburgh

Ordered an Italian combo sub and a small pizza. 1. The pizza crust was burned. 2. For the sandwich, I think, I'd have been better off with QuikChek. I got a single layer each of ham, salami, provolone and pepperoni. With GIANT pieces of iceberg lettuce, and tomatoes. (If I wanted a salad, I would have ordered one! I barely had any oil and vinegar. I understand that they're under new management, same name. But the food quality is completely downhill! Time to find a new pizzaria.

A GREAT SURPRISE found by chance on a road trip. Fabulous! Service: Take out Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Brooklyn Pizza

AMAZING!! I order from here weekly and the food is fantastic. Great pizza, Great Sauce, Great pepperoni rolls, perfectly made cold subs, and above all Great Customer Services!! They are so kind, so pleasant, super polite, and generous. I couldn't be happier with the gentleman who run this place, their service, and their food. Well done! (Also posted on yelp)

This place is under new management and honestly I think they should change the name, just my opinion. At least put a large sign outside under new management. The place had been mediocre at best for a while. The new owners are nice and have excellent quality food service. Good luck! Service: Delivery

My mother-in-law says that this is the next pizza she had grown up in the city. also good dinner. recommend the lasagne.