Whitmans - New York

So disappointed in this service. My group of 4 went on a Sunday evening. There were 2 other tables and we had the worst service. The waitress totally forgot my salad order. Burgers were missing cheese. We ordered apps and she didn?t bring out little plates or silverware. We left hungry and went to a 7th Street Burger.

First I will say I love the staff, ther are always super friendly and extremely accommodating. The food is first class. I've had just about everything on the menu, and I haven't had a bad meal yet. If you're in the area this is a great spot, so stop in and give it a try you won't be sorry.

I’ve dined here before and had an amazing experience. However, this time I tried the Philly cheesesteak, and it was quite salty and not enjoyable at all. I would recommend sticking with the burgers; they’re definitely much better.

This restaurant is located in a quiet corner of St. Marks Street. The burgers were excellent, featuring juicy meat, hot fries, and some interesting optional toppings. I’ll definitely have to return to try the peanut butter on my burger. The bathroom is small and tucked away, but it’s clean. The service was fast, and my server was friendly.

The prices are a bit on the higher side, and some might find the portions small, but I believe the sizes are just right when paired with the bun, lettuce, and other toppings. The raw onion on the classic burger was excellent, and the homemade chips were delicious. The fries are tasty as well. The service was friendly and prompt. I definitely plan to return— we saw someone order a steak and cheese, and it looked fantastic!