Pick A Bagel - Feedback

OVERPRICED! Service was fast, bagel was ok… but wow $10 for a bagel with cream cheese and bacon? Crazy. I’ll go to Bagel Boy next time.

We paid 47$ (paid cash) for a panini, a lax cream cheese bagel, large iced cappuccino, chocolate cookie and a muffin. At the cashier I was shocked but paid beca...

Coffee was entirely too hot. Want able to drink it even after 20 minutes.

Unbelievably rude cashier. She does not even speak good English herself but gave me the ugliest-looking when I had to repeat 4 times I ordered a bagel with eggs...

Great staff. Nice selection of bagel spreads and bagels. They have salt bagels... Small but good selection of fish to order, including Sable. Go in every time I...

Always excellent bagels, and real bialys that have become rare. They are really good. All the sandwiches excellent. You will never be disappointed here.Excellen...

Where do I even begin???? From the moment you walk into this place you're mesmerized by the smell of the baked goods. Their bagels are fresh and delicious. The...

There are suddenly tons of bagel shops on the Upper East Side. This is the only one that has acceptable prices, i.e. doesn't charge $20 plus for a lox sandwich....

Always excellent bagels, and real bialys that have become rare. They are really good. All the sandwiches excellent. You will never be disappointed here.

Good experience. Little busy and the shop is small. But the bagel tasted really good. I wanted a bagel with all veggies. But the guy gave me bagel with veggie c...

"Baked in Brooklyn" doesn't seem like something to advertise for a bagel shop.

This place is not worth itToo crowded and they got all our three bagels wrong.

Came here on a Sunday afternoon and the line up was surprisingly not as bad as expected! Some seating available.