Il Piccolo Bufalo - New York

This restaurant in the little Italy district of New York was a delightful find. The atmosphere was fantastic, just like everything else about the place. It's important to note that there are many similar shops on the same street, offering almost identical menus. However, we opted for this one because they serve authentic Naples pizza. Having spent time in Naples and consumed pizza there numerous times, we found this version to be close but not quite the same. The bruschetta was overly charred and overly oily, not meeting our expectations. The service was satisfactory and prompt, but we noticed that other diners seemed to be quite irritated. It's worth mentioning that this establishment operates in the traditional style of an old-world Italian restaurant in Naples, allowing customers to linger for hours without feeling rushed.

My girlfriend and I went to this restaurant last night and had the beef ravioli and pizza Bella. It was absolutely incredible. I was sweating from the sheer delight of the delicious sauce. We had an amazing experience and I can't wait to come back with my parents.

Dave gave a positive rating, and the pizza was decent but nothing exceptional. In my opinion, I would rate it a 6.7, but I am not the President.

Visited with a large group and we were in a bit of a hurry so it was unfortunate that the food took ages and two orders were missing. One was my vegan pizza. They apologised and went on to make this but when it arrived it was clear they had given me a gluten free base with normal cheese so I had to send this back. Sadly we had not got enough time for me to eat another but they made one and boxed it up for me to take. It was only on opening the box several minutes later after leaving that I saw it was vegan cheese (good but still gluten free base (not good . I’m guessing that the pizza bases normally must contain dairy or egg there (unusual? but I’m thinking they misunderstood vegan as gluten free? I’d give the place/food 1/5 for my personal experience but 4/5 for the rest of my group who enjoyed their food, despite the speed of service.

Yummy! Wonderful authentic food. Super friendly engaging Joe is the best. Brush up on your trivia ?? Salute The Lewis'