Croton Reservoir Tavern - Feedback

meet an old friend to catch up! great Bourbon selection and great snacks, modern nyc with classic subway flow feeling

to polish food. good service. very expensive, but it is midtown

very nice atmosphere service was excellent and so it was definitely recommended to eat.

terrible. avoid spending $100 on a terrible experience.

This cute little tavern was close to our hotel for our New Year’s holiday week celebration. Our family of 4 dined here for lunch on Dec 30. The server was frien...

Not a good experience. Waitress had no personality at all and even the hostess was not polite at check in. Only person who seemed like they wanted to be there w...

This restaurant is a great choice for a first date. The fact that they do not serve Guinness in pints was a bit surprising, but overall a positive experience.

Meeting an old friend to catch up! Great bourbon selection and great snacks, modern NYC with a classic subway tile feel

The food is delicious and the service is good. It's a bit pricey, but considering it's located in midtown, it's to be expected.

Lovely atmosphere service was excellent and so was the food definitely recommend.

We came in a Saturday around 7 and the restaurant was just about empty, which made me nervous. However, we were seated at the bar and was met by the nicest bar...

DO NOT order the chicken wings! Domino’s takes much better! The wings were too dry and hard, like chewing a piece of wood. The sweet cocktail taste like alcohol...

My daughter and I were having a pre birthday dinner. The place is lovely. We particularly recommend the Brussels sprouts!!! Delicious.Food: 5/5

It was pleasant, We sat outside although it lightly rained. The staff took about 6 umbrellas and pushed them together to give us shelter for our CLUB T.I.N.G Me...

I've been here a couple of times, and it's hit or miss food wise. Service is usually good, but they are out of things a lot. For example, I went tonight and tri...

Came in after late night ice skating at Bryant Park. Absolutely enjoyed their hot apple cider and Mango Habanero cocktail! Both hit the spot after our fun activ...

Spirited atmosphere and an energetic vibe. Food was nice with fresh vibrant vegetables. Bartenders were polite, attentive and responsive.

Looks like a typical cross town bar but has a great atmosphere and exceptionally well prepared food. Not a big menu but the selections provide for a nice lunch...

The food is delicious so are the drinks. The waitress was super nice to make sure the soup was vegan. We will be back for sure.

Due passi da Bryan park, prezzi nella media con il centro di NYC. Buonissimi tutti i piatti, consigliatissimo l hummus.

I had the absolute worst experience just by walking in the door and getting a hand rule he put in my face by some lady I didn?t even know just because I want to...

Good place for a drink in the evening. Prices are ok. Had good talks with the bartender. Havent checked their food, but looks good from what Ive seen.

Great little spot for fantastic drinks and good food. Not chaotic and easy to enjoy the night with your favorite people. Highly recommended. Reasonably priced w...

Absolutely brilliant bar. Great selection of whiskeys and amazing wait staff. Manager and bartenders are exceedingly friendly and enjoyable to chat with. Food a...

Good bar for after work drinks. Bartender Adam was great, very friendly. Would definitely come back. Bells Two Hearted IPA pictured.