What's Cooking Cafe - New Philadelphia

Very disappointed it’s gone downhill. I ordered a panini and it was just a sandwich. I paid over $10 for a mediocre sandwich I could have ordered at a grocery store deli. It was supposed to have cheddar cheese and couldn’t find any on it. And they charge 3.5% extra if you use a card. There deserts are great, though and the girl who runs the register is very friendly.

I had no idea that the Cafe served delicious food along with sweets! I had the half turkey reuben with a taco salad and it was amazing! The food was prepared quickly and the service was lovely.

Anna is an amazing baker, she is the only person in town I have found who will make an orange cake that my son loves, it reminds him of the cake his aunt would make for him. And then she just made the absolute BEST Butter Brickle cake for my 80 year old mom who was so excited to have someone who would make this like she used to, and the fact my mom was highly impressed and said she NAILED IT PERFECTLY!!!!!!! thank you for making my mom happy, and Mason with his favorite cake.

We almost passed on this place because it was nearing close but we decided to stop in and so glad we did. We were graciously received, all three kids were clean platers which never happens and we shared the absolute best lemon cookie! Absolutely worth a stop. Don’t sleep on this place!

Everything was fantastic! Even our 3 picky kids ate everything!