Brewsters Italian Cafe - Feedback

Brewster’s has quickly become one of my favorite restaurants in harbor country. in the heart of new buffalo, the location is absolutely beautiful.

My wife and I have been taking weeks to new buffalo for over 10 years and believe it or not that we were not in brewsters. So this time around us.

Brewsters is a hidden gem in new buffalo, served elevated Italian dishes with a comfort sense. we sat in the wine room, which was cozy and felt.

I almost always have a spezialpizzen. the toppings are inventive and fresh. I had everything from kartoffel to kirschen to habanero infused olive oil on my pizz...

Yum! I would definitely come back here! we have dinner for 2 and divided between us three. girls day out! best pizza! service excellent!

Great ambiance expecially outside. Prices are reasonable. Service was extremely slow and inaccurate which wasn't my previous experience.

Such a great locally owned business. Food is always consistent and outstanding. Book ahead and request outside seating when weather cooperates.

This is one of our favorite places to go while in New Buffalo. We've been so happy that they are so accommodating for food allergies (gluten free options in an...

The dinner for 2 option is outstanding both in terms of quality and quantity!

Dinner for two is a great value, always have leftovers. Atmosphere is nice and great service