Carmine's Pizza - Netcong

I am brand new to the area and I’ve tried a couple pizza places and this by far reminds me of my favorite place in my hometown delicious pizza! Today I wanted something else and was craving spaghetti and meatballs but didn’t want to cook at home. Normally I don’t order that out because nothing beats my own, or my moms. Fully expecting to have mediocre meatballs, took my first bite and was TOTALLY and FULLY pleased. They taste JUST like my family recipe! So delicious thank you!!!!!

Food great. They went out of their way to serve my dad anchovy slice. He's not had any in a long time.

I have come to Carmines over the years from 2005 to the present. Always very good quality Italian food and Pizza made by a real Italian family. Tonight I had Linguini with clams. Omg, out of this world. You can not go wrong ordering take out from this establishment, I never get a bad meal , period.

Pizza looked like it was 2 days old and tasted like unseasoned cardboard. The server dropped the entire medal serving tray on the table and walked away without speaking. We then asked for ranch dressing. The server puts a disgusting squeeze bottle on the table that looked like it hadn’t been cleaned in months with crusted yellow ranch stuck to the side. Me, my wife, and 2 kids left after a single bite. My wife went to Carmines years ago and was embarrassed bringing me there for the first time.

We came back home and needed to get our Jersey pizza fix. We were talking about getting a few slices and sharing them and were pleasantly surprised when they must have overheard and sent our slices out spilt in half and divided up between two plates. We sat at the small counter facing the street, so can't speek to the restaurant, or the rest of the menu which is HUGE but for grabbing some slices it was perfect.