Sugarloaf Island Bakery - Feedback

I went in today for pie and all she had was peanut butter pie. I tried it wow really peanut buttery. But I was able to get some cake And some cream puffs for th...

My husband ordered a birthday cake for me. I wanted a beach theme. I cake was beautiful and tasty.

Absolutely delicious goodies. Loved the Baileys mousse cake, tiramisu and cream puffs! Can't wait to try more and the homemade bread! Owner was friendly and ver...

Just left the bakery. What an amazing baker, he has been up since two this morning. If you are looking for a sugary no flavor dessert keep driving. It you want...

So glad to have stopped in at this bakery on Valentine's Day. I got the gluten free Flourless Chocolate Cake and it was super amazing. Light, flavorful, rich......

The reviews led us here and we were really grateful. A small but cozy room with a large owner/baker. His desserts were worthy of any accent I will describe. The...

So delicious! Oreo cheesecake was so good and the chocolate cake too. You can say the quality of the ingredients that looks through the way it tastes. I will de...

This place is amazing. I had tried to order cookies for someone in the hospital online. I had a very hard time finding any place in the area that could handle i...

So my wife knows that Key Lime Pie is my favorite dessert. Two years in a row, she got me the Key Lime Pie from Sugarloaf Island and I really can't say enough g...

We bought cream puffs, flourless chocolate cake, and a cinnamon roll. Between three people, we had eaten most of it before getting home. The cream puffs cream h...