Jack Pandl's Whitefish Bay Inn

Definetly old school. They need to take it up some to get back to where they used to be. Maybe just me with different expectations than I received.

Three out of the four dinners were terrible. The service was slow and subpar. There were no rolls provided, so I had to take butter from another table.

Very good, nostalgic German-centric dining experience in Whitefish Bay. Enjoyed the nod to 50-60's decor in a what appeared to be a house/log cabin. The Schnitzel and fish were both good including the traditional Germans sides. The grandkids had the Dutch baby pancakes...Our bill came out to over $100 which included 1 beer, tea and two sodas. That seemed a bit overpriced for the food and overall dining experience, however, the uniqueness and coziness of the space was worth the expense.

Although I know their signature dish is Whitefish, I ordered the Whitefish dinner and 1/3 of the fish was so fishy I could not eat it, the potatoes were delicious, the salad, very good but sparce, my friend had the Whitefish cakes and she experienced the same, part of the cakes were good where the other not eatable. We told our waitress and she walked away

Love this Whitefish Bay staple! We frequent often and Carmen was EXCELLENT!