Peter's of Millburn

Great food and service. Loved everything we tried. Our waiter was attentive but not intrusive. Would definitely return.

Valentine’s Day they seemed to be overbooked food came at various times no one asked us for a reservation so even though we had one they seemed to be seating anyone who walked in and therefore they seemed overwhelmed ran out of foods never got to desert etc. could just be a everyone’s experience on Valentine’s Day maybe not wise to go out anywhere on that day.

Even though reviews were not so good, due to convenience we decided to try Peter's. It was beyond busy, and we had to wait for our reserved table. We were eventually led to our table but needed to get on our tippy toes to squeeze by the other tables as they were crammed in super close together. I can't believe they were in compliance with fire code with all those people and tables in such a small restaurant. As soon as we sat down, a cold, stale roll was placed hurriedly on our bread plates no butter offered but there was olive oil on the table. Tap water was hurriedly poured before the water person quickly turned away no offer for sparkling water. There was only ONE person taking orders the owner I think. As such, we waited 20 25 minutes before being asked about, well, anything. The pre fixe food was good and of good portion size, though we were only brought one dessert. It was so chaotic that we weren't sure how to get anyone's attention. Overall, we felt barely attended to, and it appeared to us that people who knew the owner had better service. Good food, bad experience.

Did not disclose that there was a Valentine’s Day menu. Felt rushed. Service was poor.

Valentine's day they seemed to overwhelmed food came at different times no one asked us about a reservation, so although we had one, they seemed to sit everyone who went in and therefore seemed overwhelmed ran out of food never to leave, etc. could only any experience on Valentine's Day might not be wise to go somewhere that day.