Waybury Inn - Middlebury

Best pancakes I’ve ever had. Very friendly and accommodating staff.

We had a good size group of us for dinner. The inn is beautiful. We had only one waitress that did the job of what should have been two to the best of her ability. Things would have flowed better with another wait person tho. She was friendly and engaged with us and did great with the children in our group.The prices of course are ridiculously over priced for meals that are small in portion. But we knew that going into it. Most of the food was good. Some had some dry meats, which is really the reason for topping this rating at 3. After we left, we hit up a fast food just to make up for the small portions. Found out that there is more food in a happy meal than what some of us got on our very expensive dinner plate.Might try it again in the future though. If so, I will update my review.

Perfect Inn! Loved the people, the warmth and the dining! Excellent choice for leaf peepers like me! Will be back!

I didn’t realize the historical significance of the Inn when I booked it based on location from RT100 for leaf peeping. Overall, the establishment is in great condition considering the age. The rooms have no TV or radio and have a window air unit. My reason for a lower rating was the carpet. It was extremely dirty. They had 3 different kinds of rugs around the bed, and I didn’t look under them, but the exposed areas were gross. The shower is very small if that could be a concern. We had dinner and breakfast there and they were both really good. The staff was friendly, although obviously short staffed.

We only ate a meal here and I have to say it was the best meal of our trip. The chicken pot pie was outstanding and the service was great. You will be happy if you are lucky enough to enjoy a meal there.Noteworthy details: There is a lovely garden with lots of beautiful flowers.