Village Cheese Shop North - Mattituck

OMG, the variety of cheeses to assault your senses! How to just settle on 4 or 5? (Or 9 or 10? Great suggestions from the friendly staff as well! A definite stop if you're in the area!

What can I say, this is a lovely shop that has a great selection of cheeses. Also they have some great local honey and also have iberico ham! You can make the charcuterie or cheese board of your dreams with items from this shop. If you are lucky, you canalso grab a rugelach if they have some available. We try to stop in every time we are in Mattituck.

My favorite fig jam is sold here. Pre-order, it's easier.

My favorite cheese shop on the island! The staff is incredibly knowledgeable about the cheeses they sell, which is essential. The labels provide a wealth of information about the region of origin, tasting notes, and the type of animal milk used. Every time I visit, I make a point to try different cheeses. My top picks are the lemon ricotta and Whitney!

Every visit to the North Fork always includes a stop at the Village Cheese Shop. While I could find cheese closer to home, the selection, charm, and friendly staff here are truly unparalleled.