Ernie's Ice Cream - Mahwah

I got the Cookie Monster flavored ice cream and there wasn't much cookie dough or cookie pieces. It's was really just blue colored vanilla ice cream. Slighty dissapointed.

The ice cream taste amazing. I ordered three quarts for $55 and I pop the tops to find the top 1.5 inches empty as well as big voids down the sides. This isn't an isolated case, it's been getting worse lately. This is bad enough that it's the final straw, no more Ernies with Doordash.

This ice cream is so good, the coconut is really good and the peanut butter is not over powering best ice cream around town!

Great ice cream. Really good Italian ices . Just like I used to get back in NYC as a boy. My son loves it.

Their ice cream is the best! Great taste and generous portions.