Glass Nickel Pizza Co. - Madison

All 3 pizzas were great, but the fetaliscious was the best!

The pizza at this restaurant is fantastic. We ordered the deluxe and it was delicious.

The staff was friendly and the food was served promptly. The taste was good. I plan to try another pizza from this restaurant to provide a more accurate review. So far, I am enjoying my experience.

GNP has really fallen from grace. The last two times our pizza has been undercooked, even requesting well done. The dough is soggy and stretchy, not even close to done. You need to hire experienced pizza makers who can identify how long to cook a pizza and experienced pizza makers who know how to place toppings to avoid this. The new lasagna pizza was flavorless which is weird considering all the toppings. Again, raw dough. We’ve been going elsewhere more and more lately. It’s just not the same GNP as they were before COVID

We have always loved their food, but tonight it was the best. The pizza, wings and salad were the best.