Goodfellas Pizzeria Mill Street

It's not *bad* pizza, but not exactly like new york/new jersey pizza. it seems to be made with butter or vegetable oil, while real NY pizza has olive oil.

This location has been making Lexington best pizza since 2006 , it's small bit has it all , you owe it to yourself to check em out

Love this pizzeria! Always so nice and great NYC pizza by the slice or whole pie. It’s primarily takeout but has a small counter to stand and eat. I think the pizza and service are better at this location than at the large restaurant in the Distillery District. Highly recommend and they stay open late.

A super authentic, and absolutely delicious as well, New York City style, pizza lovers experience... Wow!!! Everything they have is wonderful, you won't forget it, and you'll back for more, enjoy!!!

The pizza was so good! We ended up going back and taking a whole pie back to Tennessee with us!