Little Nicky's New York Pizza Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Love this place! Great Pizza and amazing Italian desserts!

Thought I was back in NJ having the best pizza since I left Jersey. Delish!!! The cannoli’s were to die for! Hint of orange in the cheese made them my favorite!! So glad I met a guy in Food City on Sunday who told me about Little Nicks. Good to strike up conversation while standing in lines!!!

Thanks to a suggestion from a friend I stumbled upon this hidden gem!!! I am a person who grew up and lived in NYC for 46 years. Not upstate, not Jersey, not close, but in the city. For 22 years I worked for the City in a job that took me all over. Needless to say I have eaten at every pizza place known to man In every Borough. Since moving to Knoxville years ago the closest thing I found to an authentic NY slice was Community Pie in Chattanooga. It still is a great slice. However, the king of the hill is Little Nicky’s Pizza! It is by far the only Authentic NYC Slice not just In Knoxville, but TN as a whole. The other food they serve is amazing and the pastries are to die for. I appreciate people giving reviews calling it a fold-able slice, news flash that’s the only way you eat pizza! No knife and fork!!!!! Also you may see a few people who left one or two stars. I got news for you, they are probably the competition or they just have never had good NYC pizza. I am telling you, if you go here for lunch or dinner you will not regret it. Ohh and Dina and Nicky are great people that feed people who have food insecurity!

Food was great. Just a bit too much. I couldn't eat the whole sandwich.

I’ve been searching for a long time for NY pizza in the Knoxville area. I’ve tried all the highly recommended places and frankly gave up because they weren’t even close. My family is from NY and grew up eating NY pizza. Finally! Some real, legit NY pizza. The kind you fold, have the grease (yes, it’s part of the experience) dripping, crispy thin crust. On top of that, the desserts were delicious. We had a cannoli and chocolate eclair. Locally owned. Friendly owners. I just wish I hadn’t forgot my coffee cake