Key Colony Inn - Feedback

Service: Dine in Meal type: Other Price per person: $20–30

I haven’t had fried calamari and linguine with thick clam sauce in ages. The size of the serving was large enough for me to have a lunch next of leftovers. Hmmm...

Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1

Overall I was happy with the food and location. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4

I have heard a lot about this restaurant over the years and decided to give it a try. I figured a $40 filet mignon would be a solid dinner but unfortunately, ei...

Our waitress was wonderful! I personally enjoyed that there was a bit of time between dishes being brought out. Be ready for HUGE portions. The garlic cheese br...

If you value attention and reasonable service time, go someplace else. I'm sitting here 1+ hour in and had to force delivery of a bottle of wine and just finish...

Food is good. The mermaid pasta dish is my favorite. Service is good as well. Prices are reasonable.

Stopped by during a road trip. The service from server was good but The food I ordered was below expectations. Ordered a pasta rigatoni and expected fresh cooke...

Interesting place that caters to older crowd. The reviews are all correct about how long everything takes. While we were seated fairly quickly, it took a long t...

Best Cracked Conch appetizer in the Keys! We will be back again soon.

We brought our own fresh caught fish and they prepared it deliciously. Service was excellent! We will definitely be back!

My favorite place to go for an excellent meal in the Fl. Keys , no better place !!!!

Very good seafood. Some of the best in the Florids Keys.

We had a wonderful Thanksgiving buffet at Key Colony Inn. Thoroughly enjoyed the quality food and drink...

Extremely friendly employees. Fast service. Delicious food. Perfect atmosphere. Highly Recommended.

Enjoyed the food and service. Lots of Leftovers. Ended up catching several Snapper on the leftover veal.

For our main courses, we both ordered the Lorenzo— I opted for the Dolphin while my wife upgraded to the Snapper. The Dolphin was delicious, but I really recomm...

This venue is outstanding, featuring incredible acoustics—truly the Ryman of the Keys! The staff is both friendly and professional, functioning seamlessly toget...

What an incredible restaurant! The service was excellent too. I ordered the Dolphin Lorenzo with a side of angel hair pasta, while my wife had the Pasta Alfredo...