Pete’s Old Fashion Tomato Pies Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Dirty, creepy, terrible customer service and bad food

I’m very confused. There’s no cheese. Only sauce and it tastes like Campbells tomato soup. I have never in my life seen pizza served with no cheese. When we first opened the box I really thought they mixed the order up with someone who ordered a pie with no cheese. Actually couldn’t eat it and had to throw out. First time I’ve never enjoyed pizza. How does this guy have a pizza shop?

Got a Large Sicilian pie... It was Awesome!!! Gr8 traditional Pizza made the old fashioned way, Deliciously!!! A Gem at Columbus farmer's Market! Bring the Kids... Bring Grandma Grandpa, Heck bring the Whole family, Cause you are gonna be liking this Pizza! It's Outstanding, to be sure! There's so much to See do, Columbus, So bring your appetite as well! Check out Pete's Pizza, but bring Cash, as that's all they accept! Do not miss out!

This review is based off their customer service. I went to the counter to ask a question and the lady was quite rude. No other customers were there, so I don't know why she was. I proceeded to order pizza and she abruptly went to another customer who just walked in and took her order. It appears she might have an issue with race...as I'm not white.

Square pie with cheese then sauce. Easier to call ahead. Typical wait time is 20-30 minutes. It's the perfect car pizza. By that I mean you open the hatch of your suv or mini van and stand outside leaning forward so you don't dribble sauce all over your clothes. Bring a roll of paper towels! This pizza never makes it out of the parking lot. It's good hot or cold. I grab a pie every time I visit the flea market.