Dairy Hill Ice Cream - Jennings Lodge

We drove a little out of the way to come here for ice cream after a hot day playing at the splash pad and I accidentally dropped mask outside so didn’t have one to wear. I popped my head in to ask if they had any masks since I saw a sign that said “no mask, no entry” I got a cold no, and no offer to let us call in order or way to pick up sans mask, needless to say the kid were disappointed and I’m just curious, if you’re vaccinated what the big deal?! The place was set up so we’re nowhere near … – show

Pulled up a couple minutes after close not realizing it was closing and rather than not serving us or begrudgingly serving us, the employees unlocked the door and waved us in to happily take our order without me even asking, I just walked up and pulled on the door. Awesome service!

Adorable shop. They've made great adjustments to be covid safe. Masks required. Milkshakes made right in front of you and gorgeous ice cream cakes. Fast and friendly service.

I had such a wonderful experience ordering from Dairy Hill Ice Cream. I ordered an ice cream cake with Bordeaux Cherry ice cream and Pistachio Almond ice cream. Both ice creams were delicious and the cake was beautiful. I wasn’t sure about my choice of flavors to combine but it turned out better than I could have imagined and it was the sweetest surprise for my wonderful boyfriend’s birthday. Thank you so much!

Nice selection of ice cream flavors with the added benefit of fresh made waffle cones and cookies for ice cream sandwiches. Good sized space so when you're waiting for your order, other customers aren't in your way. Prices are a little higher since they are an independent shop and not a chain. But quality of the ice cream easily makes up for the slightly higher price.