Aj's Oldtown Steakhouse Tavern Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Jim and Bethany provided a great dining experience and Michael cooked our food to perfection. It was a busy Saturday night but our food came quickly and the wait staff was wonderful. This place was recommended to us by a friend in Anchorage and we’re so glad we went there. It was a nice way to celebrate my 60th birthday and visit with our son over a great meal.

If you don't have reservations, be prepared to get shuttled to the bar. Since I wasn't getting table service I didn't opt to get a steak and kept my ticket low. Got a burger and fries. Salad was very good and fresh. Very thin shoestring fries.

Dinner was amazing! We love returning to fine here.

We had a filet, Oscar style. It was one of the best we’ve had. The sides were very good and the honey Brie appetizer delicious. Drinks were also very good. Cucumber Collin’s and an Old Fashioned. It was busy but service was great. Definitely make a reservation!

Food was way over priced for quality, service was great. But will not be back, our second time trying it. Menu was very boring, didn’t have many options, and the one thing we wanted they were out of and wouldn’t substitute it for something else (without charge) since they were out of the item. We don’t mind paying a big bill, but when the food quality is equal to a steak and shake, that’s when it’s not worth it.