The Pie Shoppe/the Pie Lady/fincastle Cafe

Pies were good. Reasonably price and good customer service. There are lots of whole frozen pies to take home as well.

Very cute place. The food was really good. Especially the pie, savory and sweet. I got a savory pie and a sweet pie to take home. Instructions were easy to follow and the pies were great!! Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Dined at rooftop a few times and decided to try out the pie Shoppe. Many menu items are popped right in their state of the art MICROWAVE. Watched her take our pie slice specifically, right to it resulting in a stale, rubbery and dry pie slice. I think for $7 a pop they could throw it in an oven? they were not busy by any means. She did the same microwave routine with many of our and others food items. Whatever recipe they use for Mac and cheese was made by someone who doesn’t know whats supposed to be in Mac and cheese. It consisted of only noodles and LOTS of greasy cheese (we’re talking tablespoons worth of grease pooling on the side of the bowl). However, besides their pies, it seemed to be the only thing on the menu they actually make in house(reheated in the microwave of course). No wonder the manager was giving items away for free to patrons. Definitely a much cheaper and tacky vibe than the rooftop presents.

A true hidden gem. Do not let the name fool you. They do more than just pies. Cheesesteak was spot on. The mac and cheese is a must. The pies both savory and sweet are perfect. Save room for desert! #HeavyGapproved Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Pie Slices

This place is way over priced. $7 for a small piece of pie. Food: 3 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 4