The Gristmill - East Rockaway

Great food with decent prices. Laid back atmosphere. It can be a little dim and sometimes chilly, so bring a sweater. But the food is worth it. Pizza by personal pie only, not slice. Have a problem or concern, talk to the man behind the pizza! They're very welcoming and will take your issues seriously. I don't understand why people have one problem, and then come on here and post 5 bad reviews about 1 experience.

Great place good service. Food was wonderful ans the waitress we had was attentive. Only thing i would change are the menu prices,they are a tad steep. Lastly, the bus staff desperately needs more people skills. I know they are kids and that can be readily changed. Otherwise keep up the good work.

Food is delicious and everything is fresh and beautifully presented. The waitress Christie is friendly and helpful and spot on with your order. The place is clean and welcoming. We enjoyed everything about this place. Definitely will go back very soon!

Just tried the Grist Mill for the first time. It was delicious. We had the wings, shrimp and grits and the paella risotto. Absolutely delicious. Loved every bite. The service was great. We will definitely be visiting this restaurant again. Little hidden treasure in East Rockaway. Really recommend this place to everyone.

Their Black Angus Sirloin is pure heaven. Staff are friendly and always take the time to day goodnight when you leave. Heather on the wait staff is awesome. Food is unreal. Try their wings...a perfectly charred lemon flavor that is unique and delicious.