Isabella's Pizza - East Islip

Way too much cheese. flavorless sauce and a mushy bottom. same as all average pizza places

I am a regular at Isabella’s, and the value you get there is unreal. Absolutely delicious pizza at an affordable price, best slice in town.

Quality of food is top notch, quantity for the price though is not worth it. Vodka sauce is amazing and bread is excellent. Would be 5 stars if they increased size of their heroes or lowered the price.

We tried two grandma slices — portions are generous and the pizza was fantastic. They have a huge selection of specialty slices with sesame seeds in the crust. I'm definitely trying one of the specialty slices next time

Both food price quality and quantity is very good it's one of those places that's hold that standard for quite a while the fires are great it's the first place I want a pizza place they actually made a Greek salad and they put the grape leaves in it and it beat most prices by $3 or better boss works it and takes pride in his food the delivery is bouncing in and out of there like crazy it look like the orders are very timely though I have not have it delivered. I live too far away but I definitel … – show